Annie: The show’s ensemble earned a better response...The “Tomorrow” reprise…, sung by [FDR’s] cabinet got a louder applause than I have ever seen it get, and I, like most Americans, have seen “Annie” many a time.
- Rick Mellerup, The Sandpaper
Men in White: Some of the more noteworthy [actors] include …Jessica Kelly who portrays both an outspoken nurse and, in a brief, but powerful scene, an almost-hysterical mother pleading… to keep her child alive.
- Chris McKittrick, The Daily Actor
Men in White: Most of the ensemble is very good ... I liked Jessica Kelly who plays a nurse and a mother of a young child who is seriously ill.
- Bina Sharif, Hi Drama
Lady Be Good: Andrew Foote’s rendition of Watty Watson was an audience favorite with his silly antics and wild ideas as well as Josephine Vanderwater played by Jessica Kelly. When the two are together giving one another love advice be sure to expect laughs in one of the funniest moments of the play.
- Taylor Corvino, The Asbury Park Press
Rooftops: Rooftops is a very good play. Set in a dystopic future where debtors are forced into sexual slavery, it's intriguing, funny, and chilling, and features some wonderful performances ... [The] music by Tara Grieco… is a great complement to the show and is performed live by Grieco, Jessica Kelly, and Beth MacGregor (the latter two also double onstage)
- Duncan Pflaster, Broadwayworld.com
The Less Good:
Baal: Jesus, Jess, they had everything but a donkey up there!
- Shawn Kelly, father and very good sport